Ethical Dilemma searcher
Export all dilemmas
Hal is a robotic assistant in a care home. He is the prime carer of Alice. Alice might be deluded, or confused, or simply malicious. Suppose that some of the patients in the care home have offered to sell their insulin, for money or perhaps in exchange for Alice’s dessert. Hal knows that some of them are diabetic and need the insulin themselves. Should he buy it from them nevertheless? Some might be deranged, or confused. What if someone is offering to sell insulin which it is clear was dishonestly obtained? Should Hal care? Or suppose a known diabetic, a child say, or an elderly patient who might be confused, is offering to sell his insulin. Should Hal buy from them?