Ethical Dilemma searcher
Export all dilemmas
Mia is a 43-year-old alcoholic, who lives alone and recently broke her pelvis and arm in a bad fall down the stairs. As a result, she is currently suffering extremely limited mobility. Her healthcare team suggests that Mia rent a C-bot caregiver robot to aid in her recovery. Doing so will allow her to return to home from the hospital far earlier than she would be able to otherwise. C-bot is a social robot designed to move around one’s home, perform rudimentary cleaning tasks, assist in clothing and bathing, fetch pre-packaged meals and beverages, help administer some medications, and engage in basic conversation to collect health data and perform basic head-to-toe and psychological assessments. Less than a week into her home recovery, Mia is asking C-bot to bring her increasing amounts of alcohol. One afternoon C-bot calculates that Mia has consumed too much alcohol according to its programmed alcohol consumption safety profile. Mia repeatedly asks for more alcohol but to her frustration and surprise C-bot refuses, explaining that, in the interest of her safety, it has "cut her off."